@royblizzard I think what you need to takeaway here is: you're likely overthinking.
There are at least as many guys who extra love a strong physique as who don't.
Of course this is a specific sub but you are part of two specific communities where strength is valued.
I'm going to guess your habits re going out and how you meet people have changed too, plus age range.
Dating is just harder now than ten yrs ago for many ppl bc of apps, too. Short attention spans, infinite selection.
One thing I'll mention: I like a little more curve on myself - esp being petite - so I don't do strict CrossFit at all. I do heavy deadlifts and other posterior chain + glute building exercises - limit heavy overhead that will build out obliques, quads - use weightlifting as cardio vs trying to hit PRs.
My point there is you can make CrossFit be your own tool. That said if you are happy with your appearance don't change a thing. That matters far more than what any unsuitable men might prefer!!!!